We recently received an email inquiry about the horse tricycle pictured at the left. There’s a curved glass oak china cupboard in the background, so it’s safe to say that the owner’s bought it because it was an antique, or so they thought.
Part of what makes gaining knowledge about tricycles and collecting them so difficult is the lack of information and the other is scarcity. In over a decade of dealing with tricycles and antiques in general I’ve never personally seen any type of horse tricycle for sale (not an antique one anyway). Not at an auction, not at estate sales, yard sales, barn sales, not from pickers….and I’ve only seen a couple legitimate old ones at antique stores.
Yet every week there are a handful on eBay, most of them obvious fakes that were made within the past ten years. And some are miniature fakes, decorative items only a foot tall or so, but in an eBay listing can be pictured as if they are normal sized.
Every once in awhile, we get photos like the one above. The tricycles have cobwebs and dust on them and sometimes there is a bit of damage. The problem is though, that the tricycle appears to have no wear whatsoever that would be associated with it being 100+ years old. Little dings and breaks don’t count, as they could have occurred days before the photo was taken.
Other issues that I have with the authenticity of the tricycle are the wooden rims, which are even rarer to find than horse tricycles, yet nearly all replicas/fakes/reproductions have the wooden rims. Also the wheels are held on with cotter pins. While cotter pins were used on tricycles in the late 1800′s, using them to hold on wheels is not common, especially on hulky machines like this one. The brown paint looks to have been applied sparingly to give the look of wear, but it is uneven compared to what normal wear would look like, and yet uniform over the entire surface.
If I were to venture a guess, and that’s what it would be without seeing the tricycle in person or at least having better pictures, I would say that this particular horse tricycle was probably a reproduction made in the 1960′s or thereabouts. It could even be much newer and stored in a way to make the dust make it seem older.
For some more insight to some of the ways to tell if your tricycle is a fake, visit our Fakes & Reproductions page.